The evolution of Accounting Theory through the link between Sustainability Accounting and Financial Accounting

The evolution of Accounting Theory through the link between Sustainability Accounting and Financial Accounting

Main Article Content

Graciela M. Scavone
Marisa Marchesano

Abstract

Investors and primary users of general-purpose financial information need sustainability actions that have a financial impact to be contained in published and audited annual reports. The objective of this research is to analyze whether it is possible, based on an adequately designed accounting system, to have information that links financial performance with the sustainability strategies of an organization, providing stakeholders with information that summarized all entity actions at a given time. To this end, the disclosures on actions that respond to sustainability strategies included in reports issued by companies in Argentina that adopt generally accepted guidelines on the matter were analyzed. This information was related to investments, liabilities, expenses, and income disclosed in Financial Statements, considering the same period. As differences were detected, it is noted that corrective measures are necessary. It is crucial to open a debate on the mandatory accounting recognition of those transactions, actions, omissions, or other issues related to an entity sustainable performance, which may put at risk the organization going concern. Based on the analysis carried out in the companies selected, a link that reveals coincidence between what is stated in both Sustainability Reports and Financial Statements for the same period cannot be determined. Although in relation to sustainable performance there are data that cannot be measured objectively, and consequently are not recognized in the financial statements, lack of harmony between the two reports analyzed for each company suggests in first place that different work teams participated in the information issuance process. Besides, information needs were prioritized for different users, not providing exhaustive data. The final recommendations focus mainly on legitimizing leadership in the information issuance process to avoid inconsistencies, differences, and omissions, on training the main actors in the information issuance processes, and on awakening the sensitivity of economic science professionals. that participate actively advising and helping organizations to raise the quality of their disclosures.

References

Arcor SAIC (2021). Reporte de Sustentabilidad 2020. https://imagen.arcor.com/institucional/reporte-de-sustentabilidad-2020.pdf

Arcor SAIC (2021). Estados Financieros Consolidados al 31 de diciembre de 2020. https://aif2.cnv.gov.ar/presentations/publicview/ef19a8ee-f0b1-4301-9083-66f109735f06

Bebbington, J. & Larrinaga, C. (2014). Accounting and sustainable development: An exploration. Accounting, Organizations and Society. (6). 395-413. Empresa Distribuidora y Comercializadora

Norte S.A. (Edenor S.A., 2021). Reporte de Sustentabilidad 2019-2020. https://ir.edenor.com/sites/default/files/2021-08/Reporte-de-Sustentabilidad-2019-2020.pdf

Empresa Distribuidora y Comercializadora Norte S.A. (Edenor S.A., 2021). Estados Financieros al 31 de diciembre de 2020. https://aif2.cnv.gov.ar/presentations/publicview/526348eb-0fee-4ec0-a97f-939cff093ea5

Gray, R., Bebbington, J. & Walters, D. (1999). Contabilidad y Auditoría Ambiental. Traducción Samuel Mantilla. ECOE Ediciones.

Holcim Argentina (2021). Informe de desarrollo sostenible 2020. https://www.holcim.com.ar/sites/argentina/files/202203/Informe_de_Desarrollo_Sostenible_2020.pdf

Holcim Argentina (2021). Estados Financieros al 31 de diciembre de 2020.

https://aif2.cnv.gov.ar/presentations/publicview/d5b0135fc768-462d-9775-bc447aaa00e7

International Accounting Standards Board (1999 y mod.) Norma Internacional de Contabilidad 37: Provisiones, Pasivos Contingentes y Activos Contingentes. https://www.facpce.org.ar/NORMASWEB/index_internacional.php?c=3&sc=149&p=2

International Accounting Standards Board (2019). Marco Conceptual. https://www.facpce.org.ar/NORMASWEB/index_internacional.php?c=3&sc=153

International Financial Reporting Standards Foundation - IFRS (2022). IFRS Sustainability. Proyecto NIIF S1: Requerimientos Generales para la Información a Revelar sobre Sostenibilidad relacionada con la Información Financiera.

Mancini, A. (2015). Valorizar el Capital Natural. ¿Qué respuestas está dando la Contabilidad? Revista Contable. (31). 70-92.

Mejía Soto, E & Vargas Marín, A. (2012). Contabilidad para la sustentabilidad ambiental y social. Revista Lúmina. N° 13. pp. 48-70.

Molinos Río de la Plata S.A. (2021). Estados Financieros Consolidados al 31 de enero de 2021. https://aif2.cnv.gov.ar/presentations/publicview/bef87ff0-6e30-4157-bed8-7ec95e709de5

Molinos Río de la Plata S.A. (2021). Reporte de Sustentabilidad. Versión extendida.

https://www.molinos.com.ar/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/2020_REPORTE_EXTENDIDO-FINAL.pdf

Molinos Río de la Plata S.A (2021). Estados Consolidados al 31 de enero de 2021.

https://aif2.cnv.gov.ar/presentations/publicview/bef87ff0-6e30-4157-bed8-7ec95e709de5

Morse, J. (1995). The significance of saturation. Qual Health Res. 5 (2) pp. 147-149. Naciones Unidas (1987). Informe de la Comisión Mundial sobre el Medio Ambiente y el Desarrollo. ¨Nuestro Futuro Común¨.

Panario Centeno, M. (2019). Medio ambiente, Empresa y Contabilidad. Repositorio Institucional UCA. https://repositorio.uca.edu.ar/handle/123456789/8773

Patton, M. (2002) Quality research and evaluation methods. 3° Ed. Thousand Oaks: Sage Publication.

Rodríguez de Ramírez, M. (1999). La contabilidad financiera: un enfoque crítico, el planteo de rumbos. http://www.economicas.uba.ar/wp-content/uploads/2016/03/La_contabilidad_financiera_un_enfoque_critico_el_planteo_de_nuevos_rumbos.pdf

Roldán, P. (2020). Contabilidad Financiera. Economipedia. https://economipedia.com/definiciones/contabilidad-financiera.html

Sustainability Accounting Standards Board (SASB, 2017-under revision). Conceptual Framework.

Scavone, G. & Marchesano, M. (2022). Revelaciones sobre acciones relacionadas con la economía circular en empresas argentinas. XV Congreso Internacional de Anáhuac de Responsabilidad Social. México 8 y 9 de septiembre de 2022.

Ternium Argentina S.A. (2021). Reporte de Sustentabilidad 2020. https://amcen.ternium.com/es/novedades/noticias/rep-sustentabilidad--24095624821

Ternium Argentina S.A. (2021). Estados Financieros Consolidados al 31 de diciembre de 2020. https://aif2.cnv.gov.ar/presentations/publicview/fa7bcb0e-b38d-4d92-83f8-8f7121793290

Viegas, J. & Scavone, G. (2017). Contabilidad Superior. Buenas Prácticas de Gobierno. Buyatti.

YPF S.A. (2021). Reporte de sustentabilidad 2020. https://www.ypf.com/LaCompania/Documents/ypf-re-porte-de-sustentabilidad2020.pdf?_ga=2.104415936.1185917207.1634239947-1608431248.1631663574

YPF S.A. (2021). Estados Contables Consolidados al 31 de diciembre de 2020. https://aif2.cnv.gov.ar/presentations/publicview/b5b93dc3-3a45-498a-b13d-9f5b07ac0b89